《英语泛读教材分析.doc》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《英语泛读教材分析.doc（22页珍藏版）》请在三一文库上搜索。
1、英语泛读教材分析 英语泛读课程在英语语言教学过程中处于一个非常重要的位置。作为英语语言知识的输入媒介直接影响着英语学习者的知识获取和语言素质培养。笔者分析了国内高校英语专业学生普遍使用的英语泛读教程来说明该课程对英语专业学生英语学习的影响。 0 Introduction The textbook evaluated in this assignment is Extensive Reading （book 1 by Liu Naiyin， 2018， second edition）. This textbook is sponsored by Education Department of C
2、hina， and is widely used as a coursebook of extensive reading for English majors（usually first and second year students）. According to the author， this textbook has the following features （1）The materials of reading touches upon society， politics， economics and culture of English-speaking countries;
3、 the content is up to date and includes new social developments and scientific and technological developments， and it focus on interests and variable genres. （2）The reading material varies from 1200 words to 2400 words， which is a breakthrough of traditional extensive reading books. This increasing
4、of words can help students enlarge their vocabulary through reading， upgrade their reading speed and comprehending ability. （3）The reading material highlights the aim of training students abilities to acquire information and text thesis statement quickly， accurately and effectively. This text book c
5、onsists of 15 units， each unit falls into 4 parts （1）Text. In this part there is a text about 1200-2000 words， students are required to read the text and do the following exercises. The exercises are multiple-choice questions set for testing students abilities of getting the main idea of the text， c
6、omprehending the text， discussing in class and vocabulary exercises. （2）Reading skills. In this part， various reading skills are introduced， and， accordingly， specially designed exercises are followed. （This part is not provided in unit 3， 6， 9， 12 and 15） （3）Testing. In this part， three short passa
7、ges of about 100-300 words are provided. Students are to read the passages quickly and note down the time of reading each passage. Each passage is followed by 5 multiple-choice questions to examine students comprehending. （4）Home reading. In this part， a passage of similar length of the text in part
8、 one is provided for students to read after class. Exercises of multiple-choice questions are provided to examine students comprehending. It is universally acknowledged that extensive reading， unlike intensive reading which focuses on grammar and complete comprehension of reading materials， aims at
9、letting students read at leisure， at their own space and most importantly read for fun， in this process， students can cultivate themselves a native-like language environment， thus， promoting their reading ability. But in my teaching experience in my university， it is another story. In my curriculum，
10、 I have to teach extensive reading for a class twice a week. And the established practice in teaching extensive reading in my department， the first part- text has to be taught just like the one of an intensive reading class. That means I have to explain every difficult points of the text new words，
11、difficult sentence structure and grammar and so forth. Usually， there is no time to do the following parts of the unit which are normally assigned to students as homework. And there are no contributive suggestions available in the according teachers book. Still， there is no way I can alter the cours
12、e either in time table or the teaching procedure， because the syllabus of our university requires me to do so. That is how the extensive reading class is taught in my teaching practice. 1 Evaluation According to Mckeachie （2018） the major predictor of what students learn is not the teaching method b
13、ut the textbook. Textbooks are of great importance for both teachers to carry out their teaching activities and students to get a great access to information. When it comes to EFL learning， it is needless to say how important textbooks are. In China， Extensive reading is the textbook for English maj
14、ors of first and second year across nearly all Chinese universities and colleges， if I may say， this book has a great influence on students cultivation of reading ability. I will evaluate this extensive reading book according to the textbooks 5 parts text， reading skills， testing and homereading and
15、 the according exercises. （A）Text. In this part students are given a passage about 1200-2000 words. In most cases， it is an excerpt from a native writer and the theme of the text touches on various aspects， like society， culture， literature， science and technology to name just a few. By all means， i
16、t is a hard nut to crack. For teachers， this text is even more difficult and complicated than an intensive reading text， and they do not know how to convey successfully the knowledge to students. For students， they have to look every new word up in dictionary to get a basic understanding for guessin
17、g word from context is not useful at all， because there are too many new words for a just enrolled student so many so that the words surrounding the unknown ones are unknown， too. So， I can say this text is not suitable to be conducted in class for first-first year students as extensive reading mate
18、rial. Then what is extensive reading？ And what an extensive reading material should be？ According to Davis （2018329） （Cited from Renandya. 2018） An extensive reading programme is a supplementary class library scheme， attached to an English course， in which pupils are given the time， encouragement， a
19、nd materials to read pleasurably， at their own level， as many books as they can， without the pressures of testing or marks. Thus， pupils are competing only against themselves， and it is up to the teacher to provide the motivation and monitoring to ensure that the maximum number of books is being rea
20、d in the time available. The watchwords are quantity and variety， rather than quality， so that books are selected for their attractiveness and relevance to the pupils lives， rather than for literary merit. Similarly， Wilhelm （2018） argues that text difficulty should be within students zone of proxim
21、al development; that is， they can read the text with assistance. But if the texts are within students zone of actual development or beyond their ZPD， readers may not read efficiently and critically since the former belongs to an independent reading level that is not challenging and thought provoking
22、 for readers and the latter is at students frustration reading level. （Cited from Reza Zabihi. 2018） From the above we can see the text in this part of Extensive Reading goes to far for first-year students to engage in real extensive activities. Extensive reading should be a method to put students i
23、n a native-like environment， to let students dip into multiple language exposures. During extensive reading， students should read at their own space with the aim to develop a sense of language instead of focusing on new words， difficult sentence structures and grammar. Then what should an extensive
24、reading text be？ Using Krashens input theory， I can infer that while intensive reading adopts i+1 mode， then in extensive students should be reading text at an i+1， i， or i-1 level， with i being their current proficiency level， and 1 referring to language features that are slightly above students co
25、mpetence. （Renandya. 2018）. So， first， students current English proficiency should be taken into consideration. Students of first year of college， they just graduated from high school， and the English education they received is primarily on elementary one. They know less about academic reading， prof
26、essional words. Sudden encountering with many big words will dismay them. The best way I think to alter this part is to use graded reading materials. The grading can be done according to TEM-4 （Test for English Majors Band 4）. This is a Chinese national English proficiency test held in the second ye
27、ar of English majors. As mentioned above， this series of Extensive Reading textbooks are designed for the first and second year students. So we may just grade the texts of book 1 of TEM-1， book 2 of TEM-2， book 3 of TEM-3 and book 4 of TEM-4. By doing so， students can first easily adapt themselves t
28、o college level English study， and second prepare them for their professional examination. And most importantly they can have much easier comprehensible access towards extensive reading. （B） Reading Skills. This part provides various reading skills for students like previewing， guessing words form c
29、ontext， skimming and scanning and so on. There is no denying that reading skills are important. But as a book for English majors， only focusing on skills can not contribute much for students to improve their reading ability. Still， this way of teaching reading skills are not fruitful. To complete th
30、is part in order to help students develop themselves into competent readers， I think， it is a must to add reading strategies and cultivation metacognition awareness. Let us first look at the definitions of skill， strategy and metacognition skills tend to be simpler， smaller， more specific， more disc
31、rete; strategies tend to be larger， more complex， multi-step and involve the use of a number of skills; metacognition consists of knowledge of cognition and regulation and control of cognitive acts. Metacognitive knowledge （Flavel， 1982） consists of persons （interest， skills， knowledge）， tasks （unde
32、rstanding nature and demand of task） and strategies （knowing the strategies for monitoring， repairing， and regulating reading process）; metacognitive control （Flavel， 1982） consists of planning （setting purpose， selecting particular actions）， monitoring （regulating and redirecting reading efforts to
33、 achieve goals） and evaluating （appraising effectiveness of strategies used）. So， we can have a hierarchical relationship among skill， strategy and metacognition metacognition can help students understand and acquire reading strategies which leads to a better use of skills. Therefore， the weakness o
34、f this part is obvious only teaching students reading skills will not sufficiently enable them to use them correctly and effectively. Then how do we make it a better part of this extensive reading textbook？ My suggestion is that we could teach students useful reading strategies which consist of many
35、 different reading skills instead of reading skills only， at the same time， pay great attention to raise students metacognitive awareness. For example， we can in this part first introduce a global reading strategy like predicating， and then tell students the correct skills to be used like guessing n
36、ew words meaning from context， inferring relative information from background knowledge etc. In this way， students will acquire not only learn and acquire the skills but also strategies， and gradually form a sense of how these learned strategies should be used in different situation， in other words，
37、 have a metacognition knowledge of strategies using. （C） Testing. In this part， students are given 3 short passages to read. Each passage is varies from 100-300 words. The aim of this testing is to examine the speed of student reading and how much students can understand the passages. Compared with
38、the text of the first part of this textbook， the passages are easy-understanding ones because there are not many new words， difficult sentence structures and grammar. In my teaching experience， I often ask students to do this part in class. Most students can finish reading the passages around no mor
39、e than 15 minutes and get most correct answers to the following multiple-choice questions. This is a really simple test， but for what？ Recording the reading time of each passage of course is not the answer. It may be useful to have an overview of the time used in this part after the semester to see
40、whether students will improve in reading speed or not. Its appearance seems abrupt and irrelevant with the other parts of a unit. The whole organization of a unit is discrete. One plausible explanation is possibly that it is a preparation for students for their TEM-4 examination. Because， in TEM-4，
41、there is a similar part called fast reading which requires students to read fast and get the most comprehension. This test-wise design， in my opinion， is not compatible with the nature of extensive reading. Because one point that extensive reading stresses is to let students read without pressure. M
42、y altering suggestion is to change this part into one with background knowledge connected to the main text of the first part. It could be an anecdote， a joke， a cross talk or anything that is interesting and pertaining to the text. In this way， students can not only read for fun， but also have a dee
43、per understanding of the text， and this cultural accumulation is very helpful for their English acquisition. （D） Homereading The text in this part， according to the author， is related with the first part text. Under most circumstances， this part is often the continuing part of the first part. That m
44、eans， students is given two long difficult texts to read. As I have stated above， students get not only a few problems in reading and comprehending the first part， it is just another boring text which they are so reluctant to do it. As often as not， I ask students to read it after class and check th
45、e answers in next class. Even so， students rarely tried to do it. They just noted down the answers. By homereading， we mean it is kind of reading activity you can enjoy on a lovely day， or over a cup of coffee. In fact， students have to flip pages of a dictionary to get new words meaning， to look ba
46、ck at the first text to better his comprehension. It is more torture than enjoyment. Although， it is a good idea to stretch reading from only class to students life， it is hard to be put in practice. My idea of changing this part is either simply omit it or make it a practical one. If we do the latt
47、er， I think we can do it in two ways. First， we can change this part into a comparatively simple one. The text can be the ones closely related to students life or the ones they are interested in. There would be no questions. Students are only required to give a sharing presentation on what they have
48、 thought about the text， or what they have found interesting of the text， things like that. By doing this， students are not pressed anymore with the questions， they just read for sharing， as long as they indeed read， the aim is accomplished. Secondly， we can assign students no specific reading text
49、for their homereading. We can ask them to read anything that is available at hand， and report what they read to the class. Nowadays， students are immersed into a digital era with abundant information. Anything they read from their computers， laptops， and smartphones can be considered as a homereading exercise. Similarly， there should be no questions， and possibly a sharing presentation. In this way students can read freely， widely and passionate